Skip to main content
LKL Advisors
Schedule a free introductory call
All articles

RSU Taxes: How Vesting, Withholding and Cost Basis Work

William Cole · · 14 min read

Series 65 · CRD #7004357

How are RSUs taxed?

RSUs are generally taxed as ordinary compensation when shares are delivered after vesting, not when they are granted. The share value on that date is typically reported on your Form W-2. A later sale is generally taxed as a capital gain or loss measured from that vesting-date value. Plan terms and your circumstances can change the details.

This article is general education, not tax, legal, or investment advice. Equity plans differ by employer, and your situation may differ. Tax references below are as of November 16, 2026, and cite IRS material.

Talk through how your RSU vesting schedule fits your tax picture

This article is part of our equity compensation planning guide, which compares stock options, RSUs, and ESPPs. Here we go one level deeper on RSUs: when tax arises, why the amount your employer withholds may not match your final bill, and how cost basis works when you sell.

When are RSUs taxed?

An RSU is a promise to deliver company shares, or cash, once conditions are met. The IRS describes restricted stock units as unsecured, unfunded promises to pay cash or stock in the future, and says a taxable event generally does not take place until the units vest (IRS, Publication 5992, Equity (Stock)-Based Compensation Audit Technique Guide, revised June 2024, accessed November 16, 2026). The IRS notes that this guide is not an official pronouncement of the law, so confirm how your own award is treated with a tax professional.

Two practical points follow from that:

  • Grant is generally not the tax event. Receiving an RSU award usually does not add to your taxable income by itself.
  • Delivery is generally the tax event. For RSUs settled in stock, the same IRS guide says the rules for property received for services apply when the stock is actually transferred to you, and that the value of the stock transferred is typically includable in your income.

Under the general rule for restricted property, you include the fair market value (FMV) of the property, minus anything you paid for it, in income for the year it becomes substantially vested (IRS, Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income, 2025 edition, page last reviewed April 30, 2026, accessed November 16, 2026). The IRS defines FMV in that publication as the price at which property would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, both having reasonable knowledge of the relevant facts.

The potential benefit is that you do not buy anything and nothing is taxed before the shares are yours. The trade-off is that the vest can add a large amount of taxable income in a single year, possibly before you can, or want to, sell the shares.

How does RSU tax withholding work, and why can it differ from my actual tax?

Withholding is a prepayment, not your final tax. Your actual federal income tax is figured on your return from your total income, deductions, credits, and filing status. How the two compare depends on how your employer withholds.

Federal income tax withholding. The IRS describes supplemental wages as wage payments to an employee that are not regular wages. Many employers treat the value of vested RSUs this way for withholding, though your employer's payroll practice controls (IRS, Publication 15 (2026), Circular E, Employer's Tax Guide, section 7, page last reviewed April 30, 2026, accessed November 16, 2026). For 2026, Publication 15 says the withholding rate on supplemental wages remains 22%, or 37% if supplemental wages paid to an employee during the calendar year exceed $1 million. Employers that identify the payment separately can use the flat rate, and the IRS also describes an aggregate method that combines the payment with regular wages.

Social Security and Medicare. These payroll taxes generally apply to wages as well. The IRS lists a Social Security rate of 6.2% for the employee, with a 2026 wage base limit of $184,500, and a Medicare rate of 1.45% for the employee with no wage base limit. An Additional Medicare tax of 0.9% applies to wages above a threshold, and employers are responsible for withholding it on wages above $200,000 in a calendar year (IRS, Topic no. 751, Social Security and Medicare withholding rates, page last reviewed November 9, 2026, accessed November 16, 2026).

Why the totals can differ. A flat withholding rate does not look at your whole year. Depending on your income, the rate applied at vest may be lower than your marginal federal rate, which could leave a balance due when you file. It may also be higher than your marginal rate, which could produce a refund. State income tax may add to the difference.

A hypothetical example

This example is hypothetical and for illustration only. It is not a prediction, a projection of any share price, or a statement about any real award. It leaves out Social Security, Medicare, state tax, and any sale.

AssumptionHypothetical value
Shares delivered at vest100
Share value on the vest date$50
Federal withholding rate applied by employer22% (flat supplemental rate)
Assumed marginal federal rate on this income32% (assumption only; yours depends on total taxable income and filing status)
StepArithmetic
Income reported at vest100 x $50 = $5,000
Federal tax withheld$5,000 x 22% = $1,100
Federal tax at the assumed marginal rate$5,000 x 32% = $1,600
Possible shortfall to cover when filing$1,600 - $1,100 = $500

If the assumed marginal rate were lower than the withholding rate, the same arithmetic would point the other way. The point of the example is the mechanism: withholding is set by a payroll rule, while your tax is set by your return. Many people set aside cash for the gap, adjust other withholding, or make estimated payments, and a tax professional can help model the options. The IRS offers a Tax Withholding Estimator for checking your own withholding.

Are RSUs on my W-2?

Generally, yes. Compensation from equity awards is wages, and the IRS describes confirming that equity-based compensation is reported to the recipient on Form W-2 (IRS, Publication 5992, accessed November 16, 2026). The value of vested RSUs is therefore typically included in your wages for the year, in the box that reports taxable wages, along with your salary and bonus.

Three details that often cause confusion:

  • Selling shares to cover taxes does not remove the income. If your plan sells some shares at vest to fund withholding, or withholds shares instead, the income is generally still the full vesting-date value, not only the shares you keep. Your plan's settlement method controls this.
  • The W-2 may not show each vest separately. Your employer's equity statements usually carry the per-vest detail. Keeping them helps when you later work out cost basis.
  • Cash-settled RSUs are taxed too. The IRS notes that for units paid in cash, the amount received on vesting is includible in income.

What is the cost basis of RSU shares, and what happens when I sell?

After vesting, you own the shares, and any later sale is reported separately from the wages. Basis is the starting point for working out gain or loss. The IRS explains that when you sell a capital asset, the difference between your adjusted basis and the amount you realized is a capital gain or loss (IRS, Topic no. 409, Capital gains and losses, page last reviewed November 9, 2026, accessed November 16, 2026).

For RSU shares, the amount already included in your income at vesting is generally part of your basis, so that the same dollars are not taxed again as a gain. Publication 525 describes the same principle for restricted property, where basis is the amount you paid plus the amount you included in income as compensation. The IRS also states that for restricted property, your holding period begins when the property becomes substantially vested (Publication 525, accessed November 16, 2026). In plain terms, the vest date is generally the date the clock starts.

Holding period matters because, generally, an asset held for more than one year before disposal produces a long-term capital gain or loss, and one year or less produces a short-term result (Topic no. 409, accessed November 16, 2026).

Watch the Form 1099-B. Your broker may report a basis that does not include the compensation already taxed on your W-2. The instructions for Form 8949 describe how to correct a basis shown on Form 1099-B that is incorrect, using a code in column (f) and an adjustment (IRS, Instructions for Form 8949 (2025), page last reviewed April 30, 2026, accessed November 16, 2026). Without a correction, income could be reported twice. Your tax professional can reconcile this.

Selling at vest versus holding: a hypothetical

Hypothetical and for illustration only. It does not predict any price. It continues the assumptions above: 100 shares, $50 per share at vest, so $5,000 of income reported at vest and an assumed basis of $5,000.

Hypothetical later sale priceProceedsGain or loss against $5,000 basisHolding-period note
$50 (sold at vest)$5,000$0Little or no gain or loss
$55$5,500$500 gainShort-term if held one year or less
$45$4,500$500 lossShort-term if held one year or less
$55, if basis were wrongly reported as $0$5,500$5,500 reported gain, before correctionNeeds a basis correction

A loss may be useful in some cases, but it is still a loss, and wash-sale and other limits can apply. Our tax loss harvesting rules guide explains those limits, with IRS sources.

How do double-trigger RSUs work at private companies?

Many private companies grant RSUs with two conditions: a service condition, such as continued employment over a vesting schedule, and a liquidity condition, such as an acquisition or a public offering. The plan document defines the conditions and what happens if the second one is never met.

The IRS describes a substantial risk of forfeiture as generally existing where rights are conditioned on future substantial services or on the occurrence of a condition related to a purpose of the transfer (Publication 525, accessed November 16, 2026). Because the taxable event generally follows vesting and delivery, the liquidity condition may be what determines when income arises, and a large tax bill may arrive before the shares can be sold. Your plan and your tax professional determine how this applies to you.

Some points that come up for private-company holders:

  • Cash for withholding. If the vest is tied to a liquidity event, there may be a large amount of income in one year. Ask how the plan covers withholding, for example by withholding shares or selling shares.
  • No election at grant. The IRS says an 83(b) election cannot be made with respect to the grant of an RSU, because RSUs are not property for that purpose (Publication 5992, accessed November 16, 2026). Our article on the 83(b) election for start-up employees explains where that election does apply, such as early-exercised or restricted stock.
  • A possible deferral election. The IRS also describes an election under section 83(i) for certain startup employees, with conditions on the employer and the plan and a short filing window. Whether it is available is a question for your employer and tax professional (Publication 5992, accessed November 16, 2026).
  • AMT is mostly an option question. Alternative minimum tax is most often associated with exercising incentive stock options, not RSU vesting. A large vest can still change your overall tax picture, so ask your tax professional to check. Our article on alternative minimum tax surprises for equity compensation covers the option side.

What about state tax, including Georgia?

State rules apply in addition to the federal rules. LKL Advisors is based in Atlanta, and Georgia has its own income tax rules and withholding requirements, which are separate from federal rules. If you have lived or worked in more than one state while an award was vesting, more than one state may claim part of the income, and how it is divided depends on your facts and each state's rules.

We keep this section general on purpose, because state rates and rules change and depend on residency. See the Georgia Department of Revenue for current Georgia information, and ask your tax professional how your own vests would be treated.

Pros and cons of selling versus holding vested RSU shares

Selling some or all vested sharesHolding vested shares
Potential benefitsMay reduce how much of your wealth depends on one employer. Can provide cash for taxes or other goals. Keeps basis close to the amount already taxed, so any gain or loss is usually small.May allow a gain to qualify as long-term if held more than one year. Keeps you invested in the company's future value.
Potential limitationsA sale can create a gain, and a quick sale gives up any later change in value, up or down. Selling for a loss may be limited by wash-sale rules.You carry the risk that the price falls below the vest-date value, while the tax on the vest is already due. Concentration in one stock can grow with each vest.

There is no single answer. A plan can weigh your cash needs, tax situation, other holdings, and how much concentration you are comfortable with. Our financial order of operations guide shows where equity decisions sit relative to cash reserves, employer matches, and tax-advantaged accounts.

What to bring to a planning conversation

  • Your RSU award agreements and the equity plan document
  • Vesting schedules, including any liquidity-event condition for private-company awards
  • Employer equity statements showing the date, share count, and share value for each vest
  • Your most recent Form W-2 and pay stubs showing withholding at vest
  • Form 1099-B and any brokerage statements showing sales of vested shares and the basis reported
  • Your last two years of tax returns
  • Statements for retirement, brokerage, and bank accounts
  • Notes on any other states where you lived or worked while awards vested
  • The name of your tax professional, and the questions you want to ask them

Questions to ask a tax professional

  • How will my employer withhold at vest, and is that likely to be close to my actual federal and state tax?
  • Do I need to adjust my Form W-4 or make estimated payments to cover a gap?
  • Is the basis on my Form 1099-B correct, and how do I reconcile it with my W-2?
  • If my RSUs are double-trigger, how and when will the income be taxed, and how would taxes be paid?
  • How would holding or selling affect my total tax in the current year and next year?

How we approach it at LKL Advisors

RSUs are a common planning question for startup and tech employees. At LKL Advisors, we look across every account and award you have, including workplace plans, IRAs, HSAs, taxable accounts, and equity compensation, and we build a plan for how each part fits your needs and goals. We coordinate with your tax professional rather than replace them. If you want a one-time, defined plan around a vesting schedule or a liquidity event, our one-time financial plan is designed for that kind of project, and you can review our published fee structure, which has no account minimums.

Talk through how your RSU vesting schedule fits your tax picture

Frequently asked questions

How are RSUs taxed?

RSUs are generally taxed as ordinary compensation when shares are delivered after vesting, and the value on that date is typically included in your wages. A later sale is generally taxed as a capital gain or loss measured from your basis. The details depend on your plan and your circumstances, so a tax professional can confirm how your award is treated.

Is RSU income counted in my W-2?

Generally, yes. The value of vested RSUs is typically reported as wages on your Form W-2, along with your salary and bonus, and it is generally subject to Social Security and Medicare tax as well as income tax. Your employer's equity statements usually show the detail for each vest.

Why is my RSU tax withholding different from what I owe?

Withholding is a prepayment based on a payroll rule, not a calculation of your final tax. For 2026, the IRS describes a 22% supplemental wage withholding rate, or 37% above $1 million of supplemental wages in the year. Your actual tax depends on your total income, deductions, and filing status, so the gap could go either way.

What is the cost basis of my RSU shares?

For RSU shares, the amount included in your income at vesting is generally part of your basis, and your holding period generally starts at vesting. Brokers may report a basis that leaves out that amount, so check your Form 1099-B against your W-2 and equity statements and ask a tax professional how to reconcile any difference.

Are RSUs taxed again when I sell the shares?

The vest is taxed as compensation, and a sale is a separate event. Only the change in value from your basis is generally treated as a capital gain or loss. If your basis is reported incorrectly, income could appear to be taxed twice, which is why reconciling basis matters.

Sources


LKL Advisors is based in Atlanta, Georgia, and works with clients across the country, wherever we are registered or otherwise permitted to serve them. Planning is done remotely through secure virtual platforms, so you do not need to be in Atlanta to work with us.

Disclosure

This article is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as investment, tax, or legal advice. Please consult a licensed professional before making financial decisions. Advisory services are offered through LKL Advisors, LLC, a Georgia-registered investment adviser. Investing comes with risk of loss, and past performance is not indicative of future performance.